What: Expressjet Embraer ERJ-145 en route from Cleveland to Kansas City Missouri
Where: Cleveland Ohio
When: June 26 2009
Who: not available
Why: Runway Incursion aborted. While at the controls, an air traffic control trainee scheduled the Expressjet and a CommutAir de Havilland Dash 8-200 on a collision course. The Expressjet pilot perceived the danger in time to avert the incident.
The same trainee caused a similar incident between an Expressjet and a Southwest flight on June 3.
George’s Point of View
The trainee in question had very little experience. I am more critical of the training process than the trainee. What preparation was there ahead of time? That question is not answered for us. Perhaps this incident is proof that a training system is working, since a collision did not happen. Or perhaps it is an indicator that training methodology needs to be revamped. (Do air traffic controllers train on simulators? I don’t know.)
What will we learn from this event? What will the ATC trainers learn?
If I had been a fly on that console, I’d have quizzed that trainee on what he learned from his mistakes. One does not have to make mistakes to learn, but to progress, one must learn from ones mistakes.
Skill, like character is forged like steel from iron, in trial by fire. How else does an expert become one without the benefit of experience?