Aviation News, Headlines & Alerts
 
Yemenia Flight 626 Detailed Meteorological Analysis

Yemenia Flight 626 Detailed Meteorological Analysis

by Tim Vasquez
posted with permission

Flight details
Flight 626 departed Sana’a, Yemen (IATA SAH, ICAO OYSN) at 29/1830 UTC (29/2130L) on a four-hour flight destined for Moroni, Comoris Islands (Prince Said Ibrahim International Airport, also known as Hahaya Airport, IATA HAH, ICAO FMCH, WMO 67002. The crash occurred at approximately 29/2250 UTC (30/0150L). The moon phase was a waxing half moon which set at 29/2123 UTC (30/0023L) in Comoros. Therefore there was no solar or lunar illumination available for visual reference, and this does raise the possibility of disorientation as a factor.

Position of crash
So far, all available information has come from press reports. Gen Bruno de Bourdoncle de Saint-Salvy, French naval commander in the Indian Ocean, said the plane came down about 15 km (eight nautical miles) north of the Comoran coast (source). Another report indicates the crash occurred as the plane approached the airport; the plane “tried to land, but couldn’t, and then U-turned before it crashed” (source). This gives a tentative position of roughly 11°14’S 43°19’E.

Presumptions in this incident
The profile of the approach and the aircraft track is not known due to incomplete media reports and conflicting details about a missed approach. It is significant that Runway 20 would have been the active runway due to the strong southerly winds, requiring a nighttime VFR approach, however there are no published approaches for Runway 20 (source). The location north or northwest of the airport indicates the aircraft was not on a critical leg of its approach and probably was maneuvering at some altitude (3000 to 10,000 ft MSL) to establish itself on the approach.

Meteorological analysis

Surface analysis
The surface analysis showed that the Comoros Islands was not in a typical trade wind regime driven by subtropical high pressure but was under the influence of a decaying polar front generated by a polar high that had spread into South Africa. At approximately 29 June / 0600Z, 17 hours before the incident, a decaying cold front arrived at Moroni with significant strengthening of winds and a shift from southeasterly to southwesterly. The air mass driving this front had been responsible for hard freezes in Zimbabwe Sunday and Monday (source). Though polar fronts are normally found only in temperate latitudes, their presence in tropical locations has been well-documented in the literature.

This shows that the strong winds are persistent, spanning many hours, and that cloud cover was generally less than 1/8th (mostly clear) at Moroni.
Sea surface temperatures around the Comoros Islands were 26-27 deg C (79-81 deg F). The strong winds sustained to 29 mph, according to the basic Beaufort Scale definition, are associated with waves of 9 to 13 ft and this would be supported by the long southerly fetch from the Mozambique Channel. Preliminary model data from Oceanweather and FNMOC indicates significant wave heights around Comoros were on the order of 3 to 4.5 meters (10 to 15 ft), which would have caused significant problems for ditching, especially without visual reference.

Satellite imagery
At the time of this writing, only 4 km infrared imagery was available and no calibrated spectral data. The 4 km imagery showed a quiescent weather pattern across the Comoros Islands with no deep convection. Layers of broken stratocumulus or altocumulus were prevalent throughout the Mozambique Channel. Due to limited resolution there was insufficient data to determine the extent and coverage of stratocumulus or stratus layers.

Strong winds

Yemeni civil aviation deputy chief Mohammed Abdul Qader said the wind speed was 61 km/h (38 mph) as the aircraft was landing (source). This is consistent with observed METAR reports. While these winds can significantly complicate approaches and takeoffs, a high wind speed in itself is ground-relative and does not affect on other phases of flight except for (1) causing course deviations off of presumed routes due to drift and (2) causing mechanical turbulence and shear especially near rough terrain.

Scott Bachmeier of the University of Wisconsin Space Science and Engineering Center was kind enough to assist with imagery, and contributed these additional thoughts: “The Meteosat-7 IR cloud tracked winds certainly show the strong equatorward flow (~20-30 knots) that likely caused problems on the approach to the airport on the Comoros Island.”

Grande Comore Island, where Moroni is located, is a mountainous island about 10 x 30 miles in size with volcanic peaks to 2361 m (7746 ft) MSL that include Karthala, an active volcano. As a result, the island does significantly disrupt the lower tropospheric wind flow in a strong wind regime such as this one, and probably shares characteristics with similarly-dimensioned islands like Kauai, where damaging turbulence incidents have occurred in the past. AQUA high-resolution imagery the next day indicated convergence line downstream from Grande Comodore and the presence of mesoscale open cell convection (see Agee et al. 1973 for more information) which is typical of a cool air mass over a warm surface. While this does not propose that any circulations existed which damaged the plane, it does highlight that the winds were likely variable and somewhat unpredictable, and some shear and turbulence may have existed in the lowest several thousand feet of the atmosphere.

Conclusions

Once again we are left with another Airbus mystery, and while it appears certain that weather was not the cause, the weather conditions across the Comoros Islands were atypical and there is some possibility it could have been a contributing factor to the crash. Some individual conclusions are as follows.

  • Conditions enroute. Naturally, consideration must be given to whether damage may have occurred enroute from Yemen and manifested itself during the approach. A review of the satellite imagery showed most of the flight was completely free of weather. However a few strong cumulonimbus clouds (thunderstorms) were present in the Sana’a area at the time of the flight’s takeoff. Sana’a reported no significant weather during the evening except for scattered cumulus and stratocumulus at 3000 ft most of the night, but satellite imagery (here) indicated thunderstorms in the area with -60 deg C tops, probably which were largely confined to orographically-driven storms on the mountains just southwest of Sana’a. These would have been decaying with the loss of solar heating. Until I get archival-grade satellite datasets, I cannot say how close the storms were to Sana’a International Airport or whether they may have been on the departure path, but it does appear they were within about 20 miles of the airfield.
  • Precipitation. The atmosphere at Comoros was far too stable to support deep convection (including thunderstorms). The cold air advection over warm ocean waters did produce sufficient instability for shallow convection, and large water droplets could have existed in these clouds.
  • Icing. Icing was not a factor. The freezing level was above FL150 with extremely dry air through at least FL350.
  • Turbulence. Light to moderate low-level turbulence is likely due to mechanical turbulence from the strong surface winds and cold air advection in the presence of diabatic heating over the warm ocean waters. This could have been compounded further by perturbations embedded in the wake flow downwind of Grande Comodore Island, where the flight is believed to have crashed. As the temperature difference between the water and the air mass was not substantial, it is not believed that severe turbulence could have occurred unless the flight entered a rotor directly downwind from (north of) the island’s 7000 ft peaks.
  • Altimetry problems. The pressure was highly typical for tropical locations (1017 hPa, or 30.03 in Hg). If the aircrew had neglected to change their altimeters from 1013 to 1017 hPa from top of descent then the altimeters would have read about 120 ft low, thus controlled flight into the ground based on altimeter omissions can probably be ruled out; furthermore the warm tropical atmosphere causes the flight levels to be slightly higher than indicated.

    References
    * Agee, E.M., Chen, T.S., and Doswell, K.E., 1973. A Review of Mesoscale Cellular Convection, Bull. Amer. Met. Soc., Volume 54, Issue 10 (October 1973) pp. 1004–1012.
    * Siquerra, J.R., Rossow, W.B., Machado, L., and Pearl. C.. (2005). Structural Characteristics of Convective Systems over South America Related to Cold-Frontal Incursions, Mon. Wea. Rev., Volume 133, Issue 5 (May 2005) pp. 1045–1064.

    Thanks to Tim Vasquez

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    Plane that crashed in Westchester and killed 2 people had hole in crankshaft, report shows

    Plane that crashed in Westchester and killed 2 people had hole in crankshaft, report shows
    A preliminary report indicated investigators found a hole in the crankshaft of the plane…

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    Dramatic footage captures plane on fire as tyres explode during take-off

    Dramatic footage captures plane on fire as tyres explode during take-off
    The Boeing 767-306ER was scheduled to fly from Phuket, Thailand to Russia, carrying 309 passengers including families of men hiding from Putin’s mobilisation decree

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    ‘The question everyday is why?’ Seaworld crash survivors’ guilt

    ‘The question everyday is why?’ Seaworld crash survivors’ guilt
    Survivor’s guilt is a term that’s become much more mainstream in recent years, but if ever you wanted to su…

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    The Fastest Planes in the US Military

    The Fastest Planes in the US Military
    Airplanes first became a weapon of war in World War I. Initially, the planes were used to scout out enemy positions from the air. As the conflict progressed, the aircrafts were repurposed for aerial combat with mounted machine guns, giving rise to WWI flying aces. (These are the greatest fighter pilots in aviation history.) Since […]

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    The World’s Biggest Planes Are Finding Their Way Back Into the Skies

    The World’s Biggest Planes Are Finding Their Way Back Into the Skies
    Many of the world’s biggest passenger airliners had been earmarked for the scrapyard. Now they are being brought back into service as carriers rush to restore long-haul air travel.

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    Pervez Musharraf, Pakistan martial ruler in 9/11 wars, dies

    Pervez Musharraf, Pakistan martial ruler in 9/11 wars, dies
    ISLAMABAD (AP) — Gen. Pervez Musharraf, who seized power in a bloodless coup and later…

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    Stricken Russian plane finally removed from Phuket taxiway

    Stricken Russian plane finally removed from Phuket taxiway
    PHUKET: A Russian plane was finally removed from a taxiway at Phuket airport after it broke down during a takeoff attempt, forcing the cancellation of all flights from Saturday evening until early Sunday morning.

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    Investigators probing a possible near-collision between two aircraft on an airport runway in Austin, Texas

    Investigators probing a possible near-collision between two aircraft on an airport runway in Austin, Texas
    A FedEx cargo plane trying to land at an Austin, Texas, airport had to change course Saturday to avoid a potential collision with a Southwest Airlines jet that was taking

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    ANALYSIS: Three takeaways from Dayton’s loss to St. Bonaventure

    ANALYSIS: Three takeaways from Dayton’s loss to St. Bonaventure
    ST. BONAVENTURE, N.Y. — The Dayton Flyers rushed to catch a plane in Buffalo after 68-59 loss to St. Bonaventure on Saturday night at the Reilly Center.

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    Phuket News: Engine fire aborts takeoff at Phuket airport

    Phuket News: Engine fire aborts takeoff at Phuket airport
    PHUKET: An engine fire on an Azur Air flight to Moscow saw the Boeing 767-300ER abort takeoff and the passengers and crew safely evacuated from the aircraft at Phuket International Airport late yester

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    AsiaOne

    AsiaOne
    NEW YORK — It was supposed to be a dream holiday for Mr Kingsley Burnett, who has been looking forward to a cruise holiday departing from Sydney, Australia. However, the New Yorker got the shock of his life when he saw snow-capped mountains instead of sunny beaches. “I saw a mountain top covered in white snow… At that point, I…

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    Crash averted at Austin airport; FAA, NTSB to investigate

    Crash averted at Austin airport; FAA, NTSB to investigate
    AUSTIN, Texas (AP) — A FedEx cargo airplane attempting to land at Austin-Bergstrom…

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    BREAKING: Disaster Averted at Austin Airport After FedEx Cargo Plane Aborts Landing, … – Latest Tweet by BNO News Live | ? LatestLY

    BREAKING: Disaster Averted at Austin Airport After FedEx Cargo Plane Aborts Landing, … – Latest Tweet by BNO News Live | ? LatestLY
    The latest Tweet by BNO News Live states, ‘BREAKING: Disaster averted at Austin airport after FedEx cargo plane aborts landing, narrowly missing a Southwest Airlines plane’ ? BREAKING: Disaster Averted at Austin Airport After FedEx Cargo Plane Aborts Landing, … – Latest Tweet by BNO News Live.

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    IAF hunts for new transport plane

    IAF hunts for new transport plane
    The Indian Air Force (IAF) has initiated the process of acquiring a Medium Transport Aircraft (MTA), which will be a replacement for the Soviet-origin AN-32 fleet, procured in the mid-1980s

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    US man wants to go to Sydney, Australia. He gets on a plane to Sidney, Montana instead

    The New Yorker got the shock of his life when he saw snow-capped mountains instead of sunny beaches.
    Read more at straitstimes.com.

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    New MH370 study claims ‘three part riddle’ could uncover plane

    New MH370 study claims ‘three part riddle’ could uncover plane
    EXCLUSIVE A retired researcher claims to have uncovered a series of riddles that, if solved, could pinpoint the final resting place of the doomed flight MH370.

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    Engine problems force Vegas-bound flight to land in Lincoln

    Engine problems force Vegas-bound flight to land in Lincoln
    A United Airlines flight headed from Chicago to Las Vegas made an unplanned stop in Nebraska on Saturday after the pilot reported engine problems.

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    MTG Fans Vote In Favor of a Wild West Themed Plane

    MTG Fans Vote In Favor of a Wild West Themed Plane
    In a poll run by Magic’s Chief designer, players voted about what sort of settings they would like to see. Are we going to the Wild West?

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    Who is Lacey in Dear Edward?

    Who is Lacey in Dear Edward?
    Who is Lacey in Dear Edward? We explore the character and the person who is cast to play her after the release of the series.

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    FAA Grounds Planes In Carolinas As Chinese Spy Balloon Suspected Nearby

    FAA Grounds Planes In Carolinas As Chinese Spy Balloon Suspected Nearby
    The balloon is believed to have floated over Charlotte, North Carolina, Saturday morning.

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    Angry football fans corner assistant referee on plane after officiating them

    Angry football fans corner assistant referee on plane after officiating them
    Fenerbahce fans confronted an assistant referee after they discovered he was on the same plane flight as them back to Istanbul after a disappointing Super Lig clash

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    Cold Weather Causing Delays Fueling Planes at Bradley Airport

    Cold Weather Causing Delays Fueling Planes at Bradley Airport
    The record-breaking cold temperatures are causing delays fueling planes at Bradley International Airport on Saturday. The fueling contractor for the airlines is experiencing issues with some of their equipment, which is causing the delays, according to an airport spokesperson. They are working to fix the problem as soon as possible. It’s unclear how many flights are being impacted. Highs are…

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    Opinion: A spy plane and a balloon. How diplomacy can go way off course | CNN

    Opinion: A spy plane and a balloon. How diplomacy can go way off course | CNN
    On May 1, 1960, an American pilot, Francis Gary Powers, took off from a military airbase in Peshawar, Pakistan, in a top-secret U-2 spy plane to fly 3,000 miles across the Soviet Union, and take high resolution photos of military facilities.

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    Fluid telescope, a moon plane and self-growing Mars bricks: Sci-fi concepts that could change how we explore space

    Fluid telescope, a moon plane and self-growing Mars bricks: Sci-fi concepts that could change how we explore space
    In the past year, a tiny helicopter flew on Mars, a NASA spacecraft slammed into an asteroid and the James Webb Space Telescope revealed dazzling new insights about the universe.

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



    It was meant to be nothing more than a happy holiday memory, then tragedy struck

    It was meant to be nothing more than a happy holiday memory, then tragedy struck
    It should have been the holiday of a lifetime, but little did a group of 11 travellers know that a five-minute joy ride would soon become an unforgettable day of loss and tragedy.

    Read More

    To include the featured image in your Twitter Card, please tap or click their icon a second time.



Content not attributed to or linked to original, is the property of AirFlightDisaster.com; all rights reserved.

Site Credits